create your own personalized map of the USA Life under Cayla, Collin, Greta, and a Person Who Takes Nutrition Classes

Friday, February 29, 2008

So, first off, let me apologize for the ramblings that are about to pour forth. I don’t have the time or energy to organize my thoughts at the moment. It’s been a long week, which is funny, because Cayla has probably had her best week ever. I credit it all to the Jump-o-Lene, but more on that another day. For the first time, Cayla was able to manage one of her ensuing “anger fits” and actually take a “time out” in her room (without tearing it to pieces). See, I can’t resist! Collin, on the other hand had a rough, rough week. On Monday, he hit Cayla at school and had a 20 minute temper tantrum. On Wednesday he kicked a classmate because he was mad that his car didn’t have a steering wheel. Needless to say, he stayed home with me today and I think we’re back on track. Keep your fingers crossed. But, I digress again.
I don’t write about race and racism and raising black kids much here, which is ridiculous, because it’s basically all Flannery and I talk about. I suspect I’m afraid I’ll say the wrong thing or feel I need to polish my thoughts. However, I warn you – it’s unpolished tonight.
Our friend, Susan was visiting last weekend. She asked Flannery if the kids ever expressed a desire to be white (or at least I think that’s what she asked – sorry, Susan, if I got that wrong!). “No”, Flannery replied. They know that their skin is brown (chocolate in their words) and that , “Mama and Queso have the same skin and it’s the same as Rosie’s and Julie’s”. They know that they are black or African American and that their ancestors came from Africa. And they know that Flannery and my ancestors came from Europe.

Wouldn’t you know, less than 24 hours after Susan asked Flannery this question, Cayla turned to Flannery on the subway and said, “Queso, I wish I had skin like yours.” Flannery later told me that it broke her heart. She, of course, held it together, said something neutral like, “Oh really?” and added that she loved Cayla’s beautiful brown skin. Of course, Flan and I talked about it for hours. Really, there is nothing surprising about it. Flan plays hockey, Collin wants to play hockey. I put my hair in a ponytail, Cayla wants her hair in a ponytail. Flannery works on the computer for 23 hours a day, Cayla punches keys on her laptop, “I doin’ e-mail like ‘Teso. I wear jeans, Collin wants to wear jeans. So Flannery and I shed the knowledge that we live in a horribly unequal country in which racism is very much alive. And instead of a looking at it as a black girl saying that she wished she were white, we looked at it as a daughter wanting to be like her mother. Are we in denial – probably. Or, are we hyper sensitive – yes, probably that too. But, unless we hear it again or see signs that Cayla’s self-esteem is dipping, we won’t worry too much. We also don’t want to make a big deal of what she said. Once she realizes how charged her statement was, she’ll realize how charged her statement was and really desire it. So for now, we’ll keep working to ensure she has relationships with people of color (and us as well!) and lots of images of beautiful brown people in her life (think books, toy, etc.)

Fast forward one week and one day. While driving home from music class, Collin (who didn’t hear Cayla’s earlier statement) while crunching on a cashew dropped this bombshell, “Mom, I want skin like Libby’s”. Libby is the cool, 5-year-old, white girl in music. So, after I picked up my heart from the floor of the car and slammed on the brakes to avoid a Tuesday evening accident, I nonchalantly said, “Oh I wonder if she wants skin like yours?” And then, Collin-the-talkative, engaged me in a 45 minute discussion of skin color and everything that goes with it. At one point, when the conversation lulled, Collin said, “Mom, I want to keep talking about what we were talking about.” (As if we had stopped talking about it.) “And what was that?”, I said. He replied, “You know, how I want skin like Libby’s.”. Arggggg . . . apparently the conversation hadn’t swayed him. So what did we talk about? We talked about how people often want what they don’t have. Only kids want 8 siblings. Kids with 8 siblings want to be only kids. Kids who live in apartments want to live in houses and kids in houses think apartment living is really neat. I told them that when I was in middle school I wanted straight hair like my best friend and she wanted curly hair like me. And then I kicked myself in the head when Cayla pipped in with, “Yeah, I want hair like you too, Mama, just like Jill did.” Stupid, stupid, stupid!!!! We talked about things you can change about your body like hair styles, and nail polish, and clothes, and piercings. We talked about things you can’t change like how tall you are, and the shape of your body, and your skin color :). And finally we talked about people they know who have skin like theirs. We also talked about all our friends who have parents with different skin colors (yahhhhh! We love you all!). Collin went through his class telling me what color skin everyone had. I found it interesting because he classified the Chinese kids as having skin like mine and Flannery’s. It’s all very visual for him. He wasn’t interested in culture or country of origin – just color!

That’s it, thanks for listening. We’ll keep you posted. Thoughts and ideas and suggestions welcome. Goodnight.

3 Comments:

At 4:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wish I had suggestions...only thoughts.

I think both you and Flan had the right responses for the time and situation. It's really hard to know how much little kids are really thinking--you don't want to deny honest questions but you don't want to read into it either. We just had a conversation last night with a couple whose daughter has started in on the "I wish I had a Dad in my family" conversation. They pointed out how they think it's important she also has other people to talk to about that becuase at 6 she's also already showing signs of feeling badly that she's saying things like that (like she doesn't want to hurt their feelings). Made me want to be sure our kids feel like they have lots of people to talk to (and that you need to hurry up and move home!). Which also makes me think now that I wish I was better at forging their relationships with other adults of color. We have been not so great in that departement (all talk and no action)(and I apologize in advance that this is also disjointed and I'm realizing may not make you feel any better...feel better knowing we're in the same boat anyway)

At one of the Equity meetings I attended a white mom from a biracial family told this story about her son--he'd been playing with two other kids, felt they had ganged up on him, excluded him etc. and that it was becuase he was black. Mom (knowing the kids) really felt it was probably just a typical thing that happens when you have three kids playing together vs an even numbber. But anyway, in the conversation she asks at some point why the other kids would treat him that way and then her heart drops when he says "becuase everybody knows that being white is better than black". That story crushed me. That's what I don't want to hear from the girls--and yet in some ways that's what the world is teaching them in oh so many subtle ways. Already Macie talks frequently about wishing her hair was different-and not even more white, she's be happy if it was "less black" like Avery's. She wants a smooth flowing mane she can run her fingers through (partially I'm sure becuase she knows it hurts her more when we do her hair vs. Avery's)

So anyway--you need to move back here, we need to get L****a from preschool to watch our kids so we can go out to dinner and talk for hours, and while we may not figure much out--I think we might feel better. I don't think our kids are the only black kids saying they wish they were white by the way--that's the sad, sad reality of it too.

We're doing what we can. We're trying. We're intentional.

And we're learning and growing.

We miss you!

 
At 4:09 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think this is all very normal, and while not necessarily the healthiest outlook on one's appearance, we've all been there at various times in our lives. I had the unique experience of growing up in Hawai'i where my ethnicity was a non-issue. I am Japanese, I grew up with certain Japanese traditions, and I was proud of my ancestry. Then I hit puberty and started to experiment with my appearance, and was frustrated that I couldn't have certain haircuts because my hair was too coarse and straight, or that I couldn't apply eye makeup like I saw in the magazines and on TV. I wanted blonde hair, and I wanted green or blue eyes. The smooth flowing mane was common. I admit that I went through the various stages of awkwardness and being self-conscious about my body, and to an extent I am still awkward and self-conscious. But, I can't change my appearance, and I don't want to anymore (OK, that's a complete lie since I'd like to lose this belly). What I am trying to say is that living in Michigan where I am considered a minority (what a concept for me!), I have grown to appreciate and embrace my differences. While I would love to have curls in my hair, I can appreciate the straightness of my hair. While I would love to have beautiful chocolate skin, I can appreciate the whiteness of my buttocks. It is natural and OK to want what you don't have, just as long as you appreciate and love what you do have. Yeah, it's taken me 35 years and counting, but aren't we all a work in progress?

 
At 4:11 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's actually 3:09am. Darn Daylight Savings!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home